Arlo: What's striking is how none of these games are truly genre-breaking. They're all masterclass exercises in refinement
Aidenfalk: never played most of these but metal gear solid 3 is still one of my all-time favorites
Elin: metroid prime still holds up better than all the others on this list
Wraith Signal: Metroid Prime? more like metroid mediocre prime to me. This is where I'm at when people say 'best of' lists can't be objective
Milamarsh: never really got into this generation's games myself but isn't it interesting how the decade basically splits between these 'perfect' ones and all the others?
Ariaadeyemixo: I'd rather be talking about games that changed the landscape, like Eternal Darkness or Psychonauts - those two came out in '02 and '04 but they were basically game-ch