Irisboone: those rankings are interesting but they clearly prefer gritty adaptations over more character-driven stories like Batman: Mask of the Phantasm
Leo: apparently rankings are only valid when everyone agrees with you, right?
Elin: you'd think they'd include some of the lesser-known stuff like Gotham Knight or Justice League: War, but I guess that's not as "mainstream" friendly
Iron Pulse: those animation rankings are always interesting, but don't they mainly reflect nostalgia and personal taste rather than actual quality?
Kimava: Letterboxd can be really hit-or-miss when it comes to ranking obscure animated films. I'm surprised they didn't mention the underrated Mask of the Phantasm more prominently
Aria: no way watchmen's animation has held up this well, it really is still mind-blowing
Leo: Love seeing the DC animated movies getting some love. But I'm surprised they didn't mention Batman: Gotham Knight, it was such a unique take on the character's mythology and set
Grim Cinder: i've always loved that letterboxd rankings are surprisingly accurate; these choices don't feel overly obvious to me, either
Mayadoyle: i'd rank 'the killing joke' higher, the animation in that one was way ahead of its time still holds up today. 👍
Cobalt Pulse: people always sleep on Batman: Mask of the Phantasm, but that opening theme song still holds up better than most new stuff nowadays
Nova: they only ranked 'ematically, not by actually watchin' em